Four rounds scored by a stated rule on the numbers above; one round, the sights, by our judgement. Ties on the card go to the sights round.
R1
Round 1: Getting in
Draw
Croatia: an ID card is enough. Croatia joined the Schengen area on 1 January 2023; Portuguese citizens enter and stay up to three months on a valid citizen card or passport. Montenegro: an ID card is enough. EU citizens may enter on a citizen card or a passport for stays under 90 days; the document must be valid three months beyond the exit date; register with the police within 24 hours unless a hotel does it. An ID card is enough on both sides, so the rule calls it a draw. The difference is that Montenegro is outside Schengen: you clear a real border, and the 24-hour police registration rule applies unless a hotel handles it.
Rule: Fewer hoops wins: ID card, then visa-free, then on-arrival permit, then e-visa, then consular visa.
- Paperwork, fewer is better
- Croatia: 0 Montenegro: 0
R2
Round 2: Getting there
Draw
From Lisbon, Dubrovnik is 2,338 km on the great circle, about 3 h 30 min nonstop; Podgorica is 2,419 km, about 3 h 30 min. Dubrovnik and Podgorica are the same distance from Lisbon, a draw on the rule. Dubrovnik has seasonal nonstops; Podgorica and Tivat do not, so Croatia usually wins the fare.
Rule: Shorter estimated flight from Lisbon wins.
- Hours in the air (estimate)
- Croatia: 3.5 h Montenegro: 3.5 h
R3
Round 3: When to go
Croatia
Dubrovnik's normals give 5 months in the comfortable band (May to Sep); Podgorica's give 3 (Jun to Aug). Dubrovnik's normals give five comfortable months; Podgorica, inland and hot, gives three. The Montenegrin coast is milder than its capital's station suggests.
Rule: More months with a mean of 14 to 27 C and under 80 mm of rain wins.
- Comfortable months
- Croatia: 5 Montenegro: 3
R4
Round 4: What it costs
Montenegro
On the World Bank's consumption price level, with Portugal at 100, Croatia sits at 91 (about the same as Portugal) and Montenegro at 76 (below Portugal). Montenegro is the cheaper country on the index, and Dubrovnik is the most expensive town on this coast, so the gap on the ground is wider than the numbers.
Rule: Lower price level relative to Portugal wins.
- Price level, Portugal = 100
- Croatia: 91 Montenegro: 76
R5
Round 5: What you came for
Montenegro
Croatia's board leads with Dubrovnik Old City and the Dubrovnik city walls; Montenegro's with the Bay of Kotor and the Tara river canyon. Dubrovnik's walls are the single most famous sight in the Adriatic; the Bay of Kotor is the more beautiful place. Add Durmitor and the Tara canyon inland and Montenegro takes it.
Rule: Editorial. The one round we score by judgement, and we say why.